Where’s your evidence?
Monday 11 May 2009
“Where’s your research evidence?” The question comes up periodically (and it came up last night in a discussion on Dogme at Dennis Newson’s villa in Second Life). That is to say, is there any evidence that a Dogme approach does what it claims to do?
It’s a fair question, and any pedagogical innovation should be able to answer its critics with credible evidence. (Of course, there are always critics who will dismiss any research evidence, if they’ve got a mind to, but that – as they say – is their problem).
What kind of evidence would be needed, then? In the past, method analysts used test data to compare the effectiveness of different methods. But test scores are inconclusive, as it’s difficult to control for all the variables that might have affected the outcome. As Richards (1990) observed, “studies of the effectiveness of specific methods have had a hard time demonstrating that the method itself, rather than other factors, such as the teacher’s enthusiasm, or the novelty of the new method, was the crucial variable” (p. 36).
Nowadays researchers prefer to observe actual classes, using different kinds of instruments to capture evidence of the behaviours that are likely to influence learning, such as interaction, feedback, or “language related episodes” – i.e. moments during a communicative activity where learners pay explicit attention to a feature of the language. Many of the arguments supporting task-based learning (TBL), for example, are based on these kinds of findings. And since a Dogme approach shares affinities with TBL, these findings would seem to be relevant.
It’s been found, for example, that when learners are engaged in communicative tasks they tend to interact, negotiate, produce output, scaffold one another’s utterances, demonstrate fluency, and so on (Skehan 1998; Edwards and Willis, 2005). Likewise, studies of classrooms (not just language classrooms) where the interaction is modelled more closely on naturally-occurring conversation (another Dogme principle) suggests that conversation also embeds similar kinds of interactional adjustments (Ernst, 1994; Nakahama, et al. 2001; Bannink 2002). More than in classrooms which are not task- or conversation-based? Well, again, it’s difficult to compare across classes. But there’s been quite a lot of research to suggest that certain kinds of tasks do promote these behaviours more than others (e.g. Bygate, et al. 2001; Ellis, 2003).
So what? How do we know that conversational interaction, meaning negotiation, output, scaffolding, fluency, and so on, are good for you? This is where a certain leap of faith is required. We still don’t know what are the optimal conditions for language learning. But I take heart from Rod Ellis’s statement (in his monumental Study of Second Language Acquisition, 1994) to the effect that “it is not yet clear which kind of instruction works best but there is evidence to suggest that focusing learners’ attention on forms, and the meaning they realize in the context of communicative activities, results in successful language learning.” That is to say, where ‘language-related episodes’ are embedded within a communicative process, successful language learning results. This is an approach that is central to Dogme methodology.
So far, we haven’t mentioned affective factors, such as motivation. Research into learners’ attitudes suggests that learners are more motivated if content is personalised (Dörnyei and Csizér, 1999), another basic Dogme tenet. Again, you then need to show that motivation positively affects learning, but this is virtually a given.
An area, though, that is under-researched, but would be of crucial interest to a Dogme teacher, is whether there is any correlation between low materials use and the kinds of behaviours I have mentioned (interaction, meaning negotiation, personalisation, etc). Again, it would not be easy to set up a study in which all other possible variables were controlled. This is where an ethnographic study, based on learner diaries and interviews, alongside classroom observation and interaction analysis, might be more feasible, and at least provide some rich data on learners’ attitudes. It would be reassuring if learners were able to confirm our own intuitions that Dogme, if not more effective, is more engaging, more memorable, more motivating – more fun!
Bannink, A. (2002) Negotiating the paradoxes of spontaneous talk in advanced L2 classes. In Kramsch, C. (ed.) Language acquisition and language socialization. London: Continuum.
Bygate, M., Skehan, P and Swain, M. (eds.) (2001) Researching Pedagogic Tasks: Second Language Learning, Teaching and Testing. Harlow: Pearson.
Dörnyei, Z., and Csizér, K. (1999) Ten commandments for motivating language learners: results of an empirical study. Language Teaching Research.
Edwards, C., and Wills, J., (2005) Teachers Exploring Tasks in English Language Teaching. Palgrave Macmillan.
Ellis, R. (1994) The Study of Second Language Acquisition. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ellis, R. (2003) Task-based Language Learning and Teaching. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ernst, G. (1994) “Talking Circle”: Conversation and negotiation in the ESL Classroom. TESOL Quarterly, 28, 293-322
Nakahama, Y., Tyler, A. and van Lier, L. (2001). Negotiation of meaning in conversational and informational gap activities: A comparative discourse analysis. TESOL Quarterly, 35, 377-406.
Richards, J. (1990). ‘Beyond Methods’. In The Language Teaching Matrix. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Skehan, P. (1998) A Cognitive Approach to Language Learning. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Delta Development Blog
This blog will be updated at least once a week, so add it to your bookmarks. You can also subscribe to the feed to be notified when it's updated.
Meet the Bloggers
- Bob Dignen & Steve Flinders (February to April 2013)
- Hania Kryszewska & Paul Davis (April to June 2012)
- Louis Rogers (January to March 2012)
- Ken Paterson (December 2011 to February 2012)
- Richard Brown & Lewis Richards (September to November 2011)
- Liz Walter & Kate Woodford (September to October 2011)
- Kyle Mawer & Graham Stanley (April to August 2011)
- Nik Peachey (from November 2010)
- Nicky Hockly (September & October 2010)
- Julie Pratten (July & August 2010)
- Gill Johnson (April 2010)
- Chaz Pugliese (March 2010)
- Luke Meddings (August 2009)
- Lindsay Clandfield (July 2009)
- Duncan Foord (June 2009)
- Scott Thornbury (May 2009)
The Book of Pronunciation
Part of the multi-award-winning Delta Teacher Development Series. The Book of Pronunciation is a definitive account of the key role pronunciation plays in teaching and learning, providing a highly authoritative but hugely accessible overview of the essential elements of English pronunciation as well as a wide range of classroom practice.
DIGITAL PLAY - 2012 ELTONS WINNER IN INNOVATION IN TEACHER RESOURCES! Digital Play is a pioneering book on the use of computer games in language teaching. Authors Kyle and Graham are experts in teaching with technology and training teachers in innovative classroom practice.
Teaching Unplugged was awarded the British Council 2010 ELTons UK Award for Innovation. Teaching Unplugged is the first book to deal comprehensively with the approach in English Language Teaching known as Dogme ELT.
Part of the Delta Teacher Development Series. Being Creative takes you on a journey that reveals how all teachers have the potential to become creative. Whether you are experienced or new to the classroom, Being Creative allows your teaching to take flight.
Teaching Online is essential reading for any teacher interested in online teaching and course delivery. It deals comprehensively with both the tools and the techniques necessary for online language instruction.
The Developing Teacher
The Developing Teacher has been awarded the 2009 Duke of Edinburgh/ESU Award for Best Entry for Teachers. The Developing Teacher suggests that teachers themselves are the most powerful agents of change and development in their own professional career.
The Business English Teacher
From the multi-award-winning DELTA TEACHER DEVELOPMENT SERIES. The Business English Teacher is a book not only for teachers who are thinking of making a career move into the field of business English teaching but also for those who would like to increase their skills and develop their potential.
The Company Words Keep
Part of the multi-award-winning Delta Teacher Development Series. The Company Words Keep is a practical and thought-provoking guide for language teachers, showing how the latest insights into “language chunks” can lead to learners acquiring natural and fluent English.
Culture in our Classrooms
Part of the Delta Teacher Development Series. Culture in our Classrooms acknowledges the role of culture in the English Language Teaching classroom and provides lesson content which is relevant, useful and engaging for students.
11 Feb 16
8 Jan 16
2 Jul 15
16 Jun 15
2 Jun 15
29 Apr 15
10 Apr 15
8 Apr 15
1 Apr 15
13 Mar 15
13 Feb 15
30 Jan 15
16 Jan 15
11 Dec 14
27 Nov 14