Specificity Vs Transferability
Tuesday 6 March 2012
by Louis Rogers
One key question in EAP is the extent to which language training should be specific to each students needs and how much should we focus on transferable language and skills development. Personally when I moved from a General English setting to a Business English classroom I found the transition to be a positive experience. I felt the need for the teaching to be a performance less of an issue as finally my students and the class felt like it had a very clear focus and purpose. I also felt the same when I moved into an EAP environment. However, the longer you spend in a field such as Business English or EAP you start to question exactly how well does this course meet the needs of my students? Specificity is after all a spectrum. So is a catch all EAP course really meeting the needs of our learners? Yet if we are to become more specific then how specific can we or should we go? Also which do we place more weight behind; specificity or transferability? Would we be doing students a disservice by ignoring the changing and varied nature of academic studies by making courses more specific?
ESAP or EGAP
It’s quite a common debate in EAP as to whether we should teach English for Specific Academic Purposes (ESAP) or English for General Academic Purposes. Strong cases can be made for either. For example, there are general skills that are required in a range of academic disciplines such as listening to lectures and taking part in seminars. However, there are clearly vocabulary sets that are discipline-specific and genres of writing that feature more greatly in one field than another. So how useful is an EGAP course to our learners? And how specific should an ESAP courses be? Personally I tend to fall into the group that would argue for EGAP for a number of reasons.
Take for example a broad discipline such as Business, the Universities Colleges and Admissions Services (UCAS) lists more than 3000 courses at undergraduate level in the UK alone. Accountancy lists over 700 courses and can be combined with other subjects as diverse as Law, IT, Geology, Psychology, and Logistics. Obviously this is a very simple position to take but this doesn’t even consider each degree down to a modular level. On the face value of a course title similarity seems at times obvious; however, at modular level it can become much more diverse. Even considering single honours such as, Real Estate can ask students to specialize in three broad areas; Finance, Law and Economics. How wide and varied would the ‘specific’ needs of these students be? It is also arguably the aim of many universities, and some even put it in
their mission statement, that they want to develop students via an interdisciplinary
Of course these arguments clearly don’t negate the potential need for and importance of ESAP. Specificity enhances motivation and learning so where possible we should take steps to address this. For example, by providing support in wider academic areas such as Management, Law or IT – as many universities do. If we do go down the EGAP path we need to be confident that the language focus is actually broad enough and transferable enough across disciplines. Using for example Averil Coxhead’s AWL and the Academic Keyword List developed by the University of Louvain. Or even just by simply talking to as many content teachers as possible to draw out similarities
between courses, as was done in developing the critical thinking syllabus in the DELTA Academic Objectives series.
I feel it is not an either/or situation. ESAP is sometimes held up as something we should aspire to and EGAP shouldn’t be derided for being too generic. Both clearly has a valuable place in EAP, however, I feel an ESAP course should always keep in mind the interdisciplinary nature of academia therefore remain as broadly specific as possible. I would be interested to hear other people’s view on the ESAP and EGAP arguments. I feel it’s an interesting area for debate and fully expect a strong case can be made for both!
Delta Development Blog
This blog will be updated at least once a week, so add it to your bookmarks. You can also subscribe to the feed to be notified when it's updated.
Meet the Bloggers
- Bob Dignen & Steve Flinders (February to April 2013)
- Hania Kryszewska & Paul Davis (April to June 2012)
- Louis Rogers (January to March 2012)
- Ken Paterson (December 2011 to February 2012)
- Richard Brown & Lewis Richards (September to November 2011)
- Liz Walter & Kate Woodford (September to October 2011)
- Kyle Mawer & Graham Stanley (April to August 2011)
- Nik Peachey (from November 2010)
- Nicky Hockly (September & October 2010)
- Julie Pratten (July & August 2010)
- Gill Johnson (April 2010)
- Chaz Pugliese (March 2010)
- Luke Meddings (August 2009)
- Lindsay Clandfield (July 2009)
- Duncan Foord (June 2009)
- Scott Thornbury (May 2009)
The Developing Teacher
The Developing Teacher has been awarded the 2009 Duke of Edinburgh/ESU Award for Best Entry for Teachers. The Developing Teacher suggests that teachers themselves are the most powerful agents of change and development in their own professional career.
Culture in our Classrooms
Part of the Delta Teacher Development Series. Culture in our Classrooms acknowledges the role of culture in the English Language Teaching classroom and provides lesson content which is relevant, useful and engaging for students.
Part of the Delta Teacher Development Series. Being Creative takes you on a journey that reveals how all teachers have the potential to become creative. Whether you are experienced or new to the classroom, Being Creative allows your teaching to take flight.
The Business English Teacher
From the multi-award-winning DELTA TEACHER DEVELOPMENT SERIES. The Business English Teacher is a book not only for teachers who are thinking of making a career move into the field of business English teaching but also for those who would like to increase their skills and develop their potential.
Teaching Online is essential reading for any teacher interested in online teaching and course delivery. It deals comprehensively with both the tools and the techniques necessary for online language instruction.
The Company Words Keep
Part of the multi-award-winning Delta Teacher Development Series. The Company Words Keep is a practical and thought-provoking guide for language teachers, showing how the latest insights into “language chunks” can lead to learners acquiring natural and fluent English.
The Book of Pronunciation
Part of the multi-award-winning Delta Teacher Development Series. The Book of Pronunciation is a definitive account of the key role pronunciation plays in teaching and learning, providing a highly authoritative but hugely accessible overview of the essential elements of English pronunciation as well as a wide range of classroom practice.
DIGITAL PLAY - 2012 ELTONS WINNER IN INNOVATION IN TEACHER RESOURCES! Digital Play is a pioneering book on the use of computer games in language teaching. Authors Kyle and Graham are experts in teaching with technology and training teachers in innovative classroom practice.
Teaching Unplugged was awarded the British Council 2010 ELTons UK Award for Innovation. Teaching Unplugged is the first book to deal comprehensively with the approach in English Language Teaching known as Dogme ELT.
Arlington Ebune-Nakeli on Teaching children how to learn :
This could be a very good companion...
July 6, 2015 3:38 pm
Helen Beesley on Film in Action:
Hi Mary, thanks for your message to Kieran, which we’ll...
May 18, 2015 10:07 am
Mary on Film in Action:
Hi kieran I advocate your site everywhere. I currently work in China and...
May 18, 2015 12:56 am
Helen Beesley on Going Mobile :
Going Mobile is not only shortlisted for the 2015 ELTons but is...
April 1, 2015 3:43 pm
Sophie Rome on Financial Fridays with Julie Pratten – Stress Testing for Banks :
March 21, 2015 9:46 am
13 Mar 15
13 Feb 15
30 Jan 15
16 Jan 15
11 Dec 14
27 Nov 14
25 Nov 14
13 Nov 14
30 Oct 14
30 Oct 14
15 Oct 14
6 Oct 14
1 Oct 14
6 Aug 14
2 Jul 14